Key takeaways
- Bamboo vs recycled toilet paper compared on fiber source, softness, septic safety, and packaging, with five eco-friendly Amazon picks to help you choose.
- Top Pick: Who Gives A Crap 100 Percent Bamboo Toilet Paper
- Runner-up: Caboo Tree Free Bamboo Toilet Paper
- Also consider: Bamboo Story Unbleached Bamboo Toilet Paper
Toilet paper is a small purchase that every household repeats week after week, yet its supply chain touches forests, farms, water, energy, and waste. For readers who want a lower-impact bathroom, the two most common greener options are bamboo toilet paper and recycled toilet paper. Both avoid virgin tree fiber, both are widely sold on Amazon, and both come in soft, strong, septic-safe versions. The difference lies in where the fiber starts, how it is processed, and what happens to the packaging after the box is opened.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick answer
Bamboo toilet paper suits households that want a soft, strong, tree-free roll made from a fast-growing grass, while recycled toilet paper suits households that want to keep existing paper in use and reduce demand for new fiber. Both can be septic-safe and plastic-free in packaging. Choose bamboo for plush comfort, recycled for the highest post-consumer content, and check ply, sheet count, and certifications before ordering.
Bamboo and recycled toilet paper at a glance
Bamboo paper begins with bamboo grass, which grows quickly and regrows from its roots after cutting, so it can supply fiber without clearing a forest stand. Many bamboo brands call their paper tree-free, meaning it contains no wood pulp from trees. Recycled paper begins with recovered paper that is sorted, cleaned, and reformed. The best recycled rolls list a high share of post-consumer fiber, meaning the paper came from homes and offices after use, rather than from factory trimmings. Bamboo paper is often whitened without elemental chlorine, and some versions are left unbleached, with a natural brown tone. Recycled paper is also commonly processed without chlorine bleach and is often fragrance-free, dye-free, and ink-free. Softness is where the two types most often feel different. Bamboo fiber tends to produce a soft, smooth sheet, and many bamboo rolls are three-ply, which adds cushion. Households with a septic system should look for septic safety language, and many brands in both groups ship in plastic-free boxes with paper-wrapped rolls.
Who Gives A Crap 100 Percent Bamboo Toilet Paper
Type: Bamboo toilet paper
Who Gives A Crap is one of the best-known names in sustainable toilet paper, and its bamboo version is a good starting point for readers who want a soft, strong, tree-free roll. The paper is made with 100 percent bamboo fibers, formed into a three-ply sheet with a generous sheet count per roll. The rolls are described as long and strong, with a soft feel that suits everyday use in a family bathroom. The paper is biodegradable and listed as suitable for most septic tanks, which makes it practical for homes on septic systems as well as homes on municipal sewer lines. The brand also donates half of its profits to help build toilets and improve sanitation in communities that lack safe facilities.
Caboo Tree Free Bamboo Toilet Paper
Type: Bamboo toilet paper
Caboo Tree Free Bamboo Toilet Paper is a two-ply bamboo roll that suits households that want a lighter, quicker-dissolving sheet. The paper is made from bamboo, with no tree fiber, and the rolls are designed to break down readily in water, which is useful for septic systems, recreational vehicles, and boats. Each double roll carries 300 sheets, and the pack format makes it easy to stock a bathroom without committing to a very large case. The paper is described as septic-safe, biodegradable, and free from harsh chemicals, with a soft feel for daily use. The two-ply construction is the key difference from the three-ply bamboo rolls in this guide. A two-ply sheet is thinner and lighter, which helps it dissolve more quickly, and it can also feel less cushioned.
Bamboo Story Unbleached Bamboo Toilet Paper
Type: Bamboo toilet paper
Bamboo Story Unbleached Bamboo Toilet Paper is the most distinctive bamboo roll in this guide, because it is left unbleached and keeps a natural brown color. The paper is made from 100 percent unbleached bamboo pulp, formed into a three-ply sheet with 300 sheets per roll. It is certified by the Forest Stewardship Council, and the listing describes it as free from elemental chlorine, formaldehyde, hydrogen peroxide, BPA, fragrances, parabens, and harsh additives. For readers who want to minimize bleaching chemicals in the bathroom, the unbleached design is a clear and visible signal of that choice. In use, the paper is soft and strong, with a three-ply thickness that gives it a substantial feel. The rolls are septic-safe and described as suitable for recreational vehicle septic tanks as well.
Seventh Generation 100 Percent Recycled Toilet Paper
Type: Recycled toilet paper
Seventh Generation 100 Percent Recycled Toilet Paper is a long-standing recycled option, and it is the most familiar recycled roll in this guide. The paper is made from 100 percent recycled paper, with a high share of post-consumer fiber, and it is processed without chlorine bleach. It is a two-ply white tissue, fragrance-free, ink-free, and dye-free, which makes it a straightforward pick for households that want a clean, simple recycled roll. The listing describes it as septic-safe, and the two-ply sheet is designed to break down in water without clogging a working septic system. The recycled fiber gives this roll a different feel from the bamboo rolls above. It is firm and practical rather than plush, and the two-ply sheet is thinner than a three-ply bamboo roll.
365 by Whole Foods Market 100 Percent Recycled Bath Tissue
Type: Recycled toilet paper
365 by Whole Foods Market 100 Percent Recycled Bath Tissue is a recycled roll with a strong sustainability profile and a practical, everyday design. The tissue is made from 100 percent recycled paper, with 80 percent post-consumer recycled content, and it is processed without harmful chemicals or chlorine bleach whitening. The roll is described as ultra-strong, with 260 sheets per roll in the 24-count pack, and it is designed to feel thick and soft for a recycled tissue. That combination of high recycled content and a comfortable feel is the main reason it earns a place in this guide. The post-consumer share deserves attention, because it is the part of the recycled content that comes from paper already used by consumers.
How to choose
Start with plumbing. A septic system, a low-flow toilet, or a recreational vehicle toilet favors a roll that breaks down readily, which often means a two-ply sheet or a brand that lists septic safety clearly. A municipal sewer connection gives more freedom to choose a thicker three-ply roll. Next, decide what matters most: softness, recycled content, unbleached processing, or plastic-free packaging. No single roll leads on every point, so rank the priorities before shopping. Bamboo usually wins on softness, recycled usually wins on post-consumer content, and unbleached bamboo wins on minimal bleaching. Then check the practical details on the listing. Read the ply, the sheet count per roll, the roll count in the pack, and the total sheet count, because those numbers decide how long a pack lasts and how much storage it needs. Look for certification language, such as Forest Stewardship Council certification for bamboo, and for a clear statement of recycled content and post-consumer share for recycled rolls.
Who should skip
Households that want the thickest, plushest roll available should skip the thinner two-ply recycled options and look at a three-ply bamboo roll instead. Households that want a bright white roll should skip the unbleached bamboo option, since its natural brown color is a deliberate part of its design. Households with very limited storage should skip large bulk cases and choose a smaller pack, because a case that does not fit the closet will end up stacked in a hallway or garage. Readers who need a roll for a very old or sensitive septic system should pause before choosing the thickest three-ply roll, and should favor a quicker-dissolving two-ply option or check the maker guidance for septic use.
FAQ
Is bamboo toilet paper really better for the environment than recycled toilet paper?
It depends on which impact matters most. Bamboo grows quickly and needs no new trees, while recycled paper keeps used paper in circulation and reduces demand for new fiber. Both avoid virgin tree fiber.
Is bamboo toilet paper safe for septic systems?
Many bamboo rolls are listed as septic-safe, and several are designed to break down readily in water. Check the listing for septic safety language, and favor a two-ply roll or a brand that describes quick breakdown if the septic system is older or sensitive.
Does recycled toilet paper feel rough?
Recycled toilet paper can feel firmer than bamboo paper, because recycled fibers are shorter, but modern recycled rolls are much softer than older versions. A two-ply recycled roll is practical and comfortable for most households, while a three-ply bamboo roll is usually plusher.
What should I look for on the packaging?
Look for plastic-free packaging, paper-wrapped rolls, and plastic-free tape. A cardboard box with paper wrap fits a low-waste bathroom, and a tape-free box is a bonus.
Final verdict
Bamboo and recycled toilet paper both offer a real step away from virgin tree fiber, and the better choice is the one that matches the household. Bamboo is the pick for softness and strength, with Who Gives A Crap offering a plush three-ply roll, Caboo offering a lighter two-ply roll that dissolves readily, and Bamboo Story offering an unbleached three-ply roll for readers who want minimal bleaching. Recycled paper is the pick for waste diversion and high post-consumer content, with Seventh Generation offering a familiar fragrance-free roll and 365 by Whole Foods Market offering a recycled roll with a clearly stated post-consumer share. For most households, the simplest path is to start with one pack, use it in daily life, and then reorder the winner in a larger pack.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialA Prime membership for ages 18-24 with a trial period. Eligibility is set by Amazon.
See Prime for Young AdultsAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!